Did tax law provisions determine the value of colonial bills of credit?


Grubb (2003, p. 1779) argues that bills of credit “were always, explicitly by law, accepted in payment for the issuing government’s taxes at an announced rate relative to pound sterling ... [which] provided the anchor that allowed the bills to circulate as cash within that colony.” This general idea has been advanced by others, notably Calomiris (1988), but has not been subjected to much historical scrutiny. When one begins searching colonial statutes for the hypothesized “explicit laws” one immediately runs up against serious difficulties. One often finds a statement about the value of a colony’s currency which is explicit (though generally stated in terms of the value of silver bullion or Spanish dollars, not sterling) but where the explicit value mentioned is entirely inconsistent with how the paper passed in transactions.


Take as an example Pennsylvania’s 1764 emission, where the bills of credit were made a tender “for the discharge of all manner of debts, rents, sum and sums of money whatsoever due, payable or accruing upon or by reason of any mortgage, bill, bond, specialty, note, book account, promise or other contract or cause whatsoever as if the same were tendered or paid in the coins mentioned in such bond or other writing, book account, promise, assumption or any other contract or cause whatsoever, and at the rates ascertained in the said act of Parliament” (Pennsylvania, 1896-, vol. 6, p. 363). The act of Parliament alluded to was the act passed in order to enforce Queen Anne’s proclamation, and that act was well known to have rated the Spanish dollar at 6 s. (Brock, 1975, pp. 146-48). At the time Pennsylvania emitted those bills, Spanish dollars had been passing at 7 s. 6 d. there for more than two decades, and they continued to do so up to the Revolution, and once again after the Revolution. The manifestly false statements of the value of bills of credit made in colonial statutes were so notorious that in Massachusetts they called forth a sermon denouncing the practice (Appleton, 1748). The rates at which statutes decreed bills were to be accepted cannot be said to have “anchored” the value of the bills.


On other occasions, the way that a colony’s currency was to be valued in private and public transactions is nowhere addressed in the statute book. An excellent example of this practice may be found in Pennsylvania’s 1723 tender law, reproduced earlier. That act declared the bills would extinguish debt “as if the current silver coin of this province had been offered and tendered” (Pennsylvania, 1896-, vol. 3, p. 329). This construction leaves entirely unanswered the value of the silver coin in terms of paper money. A similar ambiguity can be found in the New York colonial statutes.


It is not hard to fathom the reason such colonial statutes were dishonest or evasive. The aforementioned act of Parliament, had it been enforced, would have required a sizable deflation in most American colonies, and the colonies were understandably eager to evade the act’s provisions. For the most part, the colonies were successful and coins passed by custom at rates in excess of those permitted by the act (McCusker, 1978, p. 126). However, most colonies were required to submit their legislation to London for review, and if anything in the legislation was found to be inconsistent with British law, the Imperial authorities were supposed to declare the offending acts null and void. While the overworked bureaucracy in London sometimes erred, and allowed provisions inconsistent with acts of Parliament to slip through, it would have been foolhardy for any colonial legislature to routinely pass legislation that explicitly put a value on colonial currency in defiance of Queen Anne’s proclamation. Colonial legislatures typically met the challenge by including provisions suggesting compliance where none was forthcoming (e.g. Pennsylvania 1764) or else leaving the matter hazy so that it could be clarified by local judges (e.g. Pennsylvania 1723).